What was the primary conclusion of the nine-judge Constitution Bench led by Chief Justice of India D.Y. Chandrachud regarding the power of State legislatures to tax mineral-bearing lands?
The nine-judge Constitution Bench, led by Chief Justice of India D.Y. Chandrachud, ruled by an 8:1 majority that States have the unlimited right to tax mineral-bearing lands and quarries. The judgment emphasized that Parliament cannot limit this power of the State legislatures, as restricting States' taxing powers would impact their ability to raise revenue. This, in turn, affects their capacity to deliver welfare schemes and services, which is crucial for maintaining fiscal federalism. The court clarified that the Mines and Minerals (Development and Regulation) Act of 1957 cannot prevent States from legislating on the taxation of mining lands and quarries. Additionally, it was noted that the royalty paid by mining leaseholders to States is not considered a tax but a contractual consideration for mineral rights. The power of the States to tax mines and quarries is derived from Article 246 read with Entry 49 (tax on lands and buildings) in the State List of the Seventh Schedule of the Constitution. The sole dissenting opinion by Justice B.V. Nagarathna agreed that royalty is not a tax but held that the States' power to tax under Entry 49 did not include mineral-bearing lands.
The total age of A, B and C eight years hence will be 98 years. Find the age of C three years hence, if the present age of A and B is 30 years and 25 ye...
The sum of the present ages of two cousins is 54 years. Eleven years ago, the older one was thrice as old as the younger one. What is the present age of...
A's age : B's age is 4 : 3. After 6 years, A will be 26 years. What is B's present age?
Present ages of P and Q are in the ratio 3:5 respectively. If Q’s age, 16 years hence from now will be 6 times of P’s age, 6 years ago from now, the...
The respective ratio of the present ages of A and B is 2:3. The present age of C is 20% more than that of B. The sum of the present ages of A, B and C i...
The current ratio of the ages of 'Armaan' and 'Bittu' is such that six years from now, it will be 5:4, respectively. Presently, 'Chetna's age exceeds 'B...
A is 4 years older than B while C is 6 years younger than B. The ratio of age of A, 5 years hence and age of B, 3 years ago is 3:2. What was age of C, 6...
Before 8 years ago, the ratio of age of anil and Sunil is 5:7, after 6 years from now the ratio of their ages become 7:9, find the sum of present age of...
Rohan's present age is 3/7 times the age of his mother. After four years, he will be one- half of the age of his mother. How old is his mother at present?
The average age of a group of 20 persons is found to be 27 years. Later it is found that age of two of the persons is calculated as 25 and 30 instead of...